Do you want beautiful coins at your door? Fast / FREE Shipping. "Jay is the Next David Hall of Coins." -Larry Shapiro "ORDER NOW!"
"BUILT BY YOU, COLLECTORS, MADE FOR YOU" Trusted since May 2007, Jay's Rare Coins® & Bullion was made by a collector and self professed grader to resell to collectors and is a very trusted, long-standing member of the American Numismatic Association, Collector's Universe, PCGS Collector's Club, and numerous local coin clubs, where he also serves on various boards, demonstrating great dedication and expertise. As a Top Rated Seller on eBay for several years, he prides himself on providing excellent customer service, accurate photographs, and fast shipping. When you shop at Jay's Pretty Rare Coins®, you are choosing a very knowledgeable and reliable trading connoisseur dedicated to assembling your next best collection now.
New Items
1796 ITALY NAPLES & SICILY 120 GRANA FERDINAND IV NGC AU58 SHINY LUSTER GORGEOUS!
$2,200.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1875 Proof Seated Liberty Dime PF65 Mind Blowing One of a Kind toned Monster Toner!!!
$9,200.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1930-S Standing Liberty Quarter ANACS VF20 Missing Shield Clashed E
$199.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
135
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
219
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
FEATURED
1966 F GERMANY 5 MARK SILVER PROOF GORGEOUS RAINBOW COLOR!!!
$400.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
NEW INVENTORY
1888-O Hot Lips Vam-4 Dramatic Error / Variety Circulated Rare Key Date Coin
$500.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
Hadrian AR Hemidrachm Caesarea, Cappadocia Near Mint State
$800.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1871 California Fractional Gold PCGS AU58 (BG-838) – California Fractional Gold
$699.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1925 Silver Mercury Dime Minor Rainbow Value Rainbow Silver Coin!
$48.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1940 Monster Toned Silver Mercury Dime Monster Rainbows CIRC!
$599.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1909 VDB Lincoln Wheat Cent NGC MS64 Beautiful Purple Patinas
$299.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
United States Coinage!
1942 Rustic Washington Silver 90% Quarter pocket piece dirty!!
$8.30
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
MEGA MONSTER RAINBOW 1938-D BUFFALO NICKEL BEAUTIFUL RAINBOW TONING PCGS MS64
$299.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
1904-O MASSIVE DMPL MS65 CLEAN CHEAK MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR PCI MS65 DMPL..!!
$1,360.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
EXTREME COLOR TONED. 1840 LIBERTY SEATED HALF DIME AU50 PCGS GLOWING COLOR!
$1,140.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
Bullion
1804 DRAPED BUST DOLLAR ROUND AMAZINGLY TRUE RELIEF 2 OZ INTAGLIO MINT .999
$430.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
Foreign
2021 Inca Sun God 1 oz Silver Coin .999 Palau VERY BOLD DESIGN
$470.00
Add to Watchlist
Add to Watchlist
REVIEWS BY OUR CLIENTS
Hey man I really appreciate the bar and Great communication and awesome packaging look forward to more deals.
His selection of German coins especially the Max Planck coins were phenomenal.
Columbian was in Good condition, Satisfied Customer...
Great Coin seller, Great Seller Easy to work with, Highly Recommend!
Gold and silver are timeless assets that will always retain their value, serving as reliable stores of wealth and practical for everyday needs. I’ve relied on Jay's Coins for years because of their integrity, expertise, and exceptional service. They are undoubtedly my go-to source for purchasing precious metals, and I confidently recommend them to anyone looking to invest in assets with enduring and long term worth.
Glad you're back! Got that toned merc dime off you. Will be back for more. Great dealer.
He threw in a free coin! How cool!
Great service. Great Buffalo Nickel. Definitely undergraded and seller made a good deal to make it work!
Previous
Next











